top of page

The Limper - Identifying Carmine Infantino's Input to the Phantom

Up until recently majority of Phantom phans did not know when legendary artist Carmine Infantino worked on the Phantom Sunday strip in-between Wilson McCoy and Bill Lignante. Now after some close inspections in correspondence with several phans we are confident we now know.

Carmine Infantino was an American comic book artist and editor who played a major force in the Silver Age of Comic Books. He was inducted into the Comic Book Hall of Fame in 2000 and cited in Comics Buyer's Guide Millennium Poll as the greatest penciller of all time.

After the death of Wilson McCoy, the artist of The Phantom comic strip, Carmine Infantino helped finish one of his last stories with the Sunday strip The Limper. It is believed that Infantino only drew one Sunday page while the remainder of the story was continued by Bill Lignante. The magic date we believe is the 24 September 1961 which is today 57 years ago.

Carmine Infantino was a strong candidate for taking over the Phantom Sunday strip after McCoy's death; however the job was ultimately given to Sy Barry.

Below we will show the three Sundays and then list below the differences in the art and style which we believe help identify the three artists.

17th September 1961 - Wilson McCoys Last Sunday

  • Notice the title panel with Wilson McCoy credited

  • Gurans hat

  • Tiger

  • Natives including the way the hair is tied up on the head

  • No ears in the Phantoms cowl

  • Simplicity of the hunters outfit

24th September 1961 - Carmine Infantino Only Sunday

  • No artist credit in the title panel

  • Tigers face

  • Gurans hat

  • Way Hero is drawn

  • No Devil shown

  • Natives have hair

  • Hunters outfit more detailed

1st October 1961 - Bill Lignante First Sunday

  • Tigers Face

  • Gurans Hat

  • Hero different

  • Some natives have the same as Wilson McCoy hair tied up on his head

  • High grass drawn differently

  • Devil has now joined the Phantom

Hope you enjoy insights like this of Phantom history, if you do please let us know so we can bring more to you.

Thanks goes to Ivan Pederson from IPComics who supplied me with the clean strips above so we can identify the differences between the artists.

Recent Phantom Happenings

Thanks for subscribing!

Patreon Support button.jpg
Jim Shepherd2_edited.jpg
bottom of page